Ninja Creami Fairlife Protein Ice Cream Recipes
Featured Recipes:
Why Use Fairlife Milk in Ninja Creami Recipes?
Higher Protein Than Regular Milk With Better Macros
Using Fairlife milk in Ninja Creami recipes gives you a rich, creamy texture with more protein and less carbs than regular milk. It’s the ultimate base for ninja creami fairlife protein ice cream that doesn’t just taste good, it fits your macros too.
Creamier Texture Without Needing Heavy Cream
One of the best hacks for making ultra-creamy, high-protein ice cream is using Fairlife milk in your Ninja Creami recipe. Unlike regular milk, Fairlife is ultra-filtered, meaning it packs in more protein and less sugar, which is exactly what you want in a ninja creami fairlife protein ice cream. You get that rich, velvety texture you’d expect from traditional recipes that use heavy cream, but with a much better macro profile.
Because Fairlife is so much higher in protein and lower in lactose, it freezes beautifully and re-spins like a dream. If you’ve ever wondered why we use Fairlife milk in Ninja Creami recipes, this is why. It enhances texture and boosts protein without adding unnecessary fat or carbs. Whether you’re bulking, cutting, or just trying to keep your nutrition on track, a ninja creami Fairlife recipe is your best bet for flavor and function.
Better For Blood Sugar Control and Satiety
Replacing regular milk with Fairlife milk in these recipes won’t only improve the texture, but it’s also a smart move for better blood sugar control and satiety. Because Fairlife milk is lower in sugar and higher in protein, it helps to slow digestion which reduces blood sugar spikes. This makes your Fairlife Ninja Creami recipe not only more macro friendly, but also more balanced for energy and hunger regulation.
If you’re looking for an ice cream recipe that satisfies cravings and keeps you fuller longer, this recipe is the perfect base to build from. It’s no surprise more people are turning to ninja creami Fairlife recipes for high-protein, low-glycemic alternatives. It’s because they actually taste good!
Some of Our Favorite Fairlife Ninja Creami Recipes
Fruity Pebble Cereal Milk Protein Ice Cream
Macros for the WHOLE Pint w/out Mix-Ins:
284 Cals, 26g Carbs, 4g Fat, 36g Protein
Macros for the WHOLE Pint w/Fruity Pebble Mix-Ins:
365 Cals, 43g Carbs, 5g Fat, 37g Protein
If childhood nostalgia and macro-friendly gains had a weirdly delicious baby, this Fruity Pebble Cereal Milk recipe would be it. With just 284 calories and 36g of protein (or 365 calories and 37g of protein with mix-ins), this recipe delivers creamy texture, vibrant flavor, and next-level satisfaction. Use Fairlife milk in this Ninja Creami recipe to give it a rich consistency, provide a lower fat content, and a solid protein punch. Save this ninja creami fairlife recipe and taste the rainbow with better macros.
Birthday Cake Batter Protein Ice Cream
Macros for the WHOLE Pint w/out sprinkles:
255 Cals, 17g Carbs, 4g Fat, 36g Protein
Macros for the WHOLE Pint w/sprinkles:
353 Cals, 32g Carbs, 9g Fat, 36g Protein
This macro friendly Birthday Cake Batter Protein Ice Cream Ninja Creami recipe tastes just like birthday cake batter, but it’s packed with protein and way easier on your macros. At 255 calories and 36g of protein without mix-ins or 353 calories with the mix-ins, it’s sweet, creamy, and made with Fairlife milk for that rich texture without the extra fat. If you’ve been looking for a healthy treat that tastes like a dessert but fits your goals, this birthday cake batter protein ice cream checks every box – sprinkles and all.
Butterfinger Protein Ice Cream
Macros for the WHOLE Pint w/out mix-ins:
306 Cals, 23g Carbs, 6g Fat, 40g Protein
Macros for the WHOLE Pint w/mix-ins:
442 Cals, 41g Carbs, 11g Fat, 43g Protein
This English Toffee-inspired Fairlife Ninja Creami recipe is your go-to for rich, buttery flavor without the sugar crash. Packed with protein and creamy in texture, this recipe hits your macros perfectly. It’s 306 calories and 40g protein or 442 calories and 43g protein with the mix-ins. Use Fairlife milk in this Ninja Creami recipe to gives this Butterfinger Protein Ice Cream its ultra creamy feel without the extra fat. Whether you want a sweet treat or a post-workout fueler, this recipe checks all the boxes for taste, texture, and protein power.
Reese's Protein Ice Cream
Macros for the WHOLE Pint w/out Mix-Ins:
404 Cals, 30g Carbs, 8g Fat, 53g Protein
Macros for the WHOLE Pint w/Mix-Ins:
526 Cals, 44g Carbs, 14g Fat, 56g Protein
This Fairlife Ninja Creami recipe turns your favorite peanut butter and chocolate combo into a macro friendly dessert. The secret to this rich, creamy treat is the Ninja Creami Fairlife protein ice cream base. Fairlife milk offers more protein and creaminess than regular milk. Fairlife milk in this Ninja Creami recipe creates a smooth texture and better macros. Try this Reese’s Protein Ice Cream delicious Ninja Creami Fairlife recipe for a satisfying post-workout scoop that hits all your goals.
Oreo Cereal Milk Protein Ice Cream
Macros for the WHOLE Pint w/out Mix-Ins:
301 Cals, 26g Carbs, 5g Fat, 38g Protein
Macros for the WHOLE Pint w/OREO Thins Mix-Ins:
368 Cals, 36g Carbs, 8g Fat, 38g Protein
Craving something sweet and crunchy? This Fairlife Ninja Creami recipe uses Fairlife milk for that signature creamy texture you want in your Ninja Creami Fairlife protein ice cream. Fairlife milk in this recipe is the key to higher protein and lower sugar. It’s perfect for macro-conscious treat lovers. Enjoy this easy Oreo Cereal Milk Protein Ice Cream recipe that brings Oreo flavor without the guilt.
Frosted Lemonade Protein Ice Cream
Macros for WHOLE Pint:
246 Cals, 22g Carbs, 2g Fat, 35g Protein
The Frosted Lemonade Protein Ice Cream is bright and refreshing Fairlife Ninja Creami recipe combines zesty lemon with creamy Fairlife milk to deliver a macro friendly dessert. The Ninja Creami Fairlife protein ice cream base is packed with protein and has the perfect creamy consistency. The Fairlife milk boosts the protein content and is smooth unlike any other milk. This recipe is a light, tangy treat you’ll want on repeat.
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Protein Ice Cream
Macros for the WHOLE Pint w/out mix ins:
302 Cals, 18g Carbs, 4g Fat, 45g Protein
Macros for the WHOLE Pint w/all mix ins:
459 Cals, 35g Carbs, 10g Fat, 55g Protein
Get ready for a buttery, protein-packed treat with this Fairlife Ninja Creami recipe! This Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Protein Ice Cream recipe combines rich chocolate chip cookie dough flavor with creamy texture, all thanks to Fairlife milk’s superior protein profile. At 459 calories and 55g of protein per pint with mix-ins, this recipe is perfect for satisfying sweet cravings while staying on track. Fairlife milk delivers creaminess without the excess fat, making every scoop indulgent and macro friendly.
Cosmic Brownie Protein Ice Cream
Macros for the WHOLE Pint:
297 Cals, 21g Carbs, 5g Fat, 42g Protein
Indulge in this Fairlife Ninja Creami recipe that’s packed with a rich chocolate brownie flavor and a whole lot of protein. This Ninja Creami Fairlife protein ice cream blends Fairlife milk with chocolate whey/casein protein and brownie batter cookie butter powder for a creamy treat that’s just 297 calories and 42g of protein per pint. The Fairlife milk in Ninja Creami creates a creamy texture with better macros so you can enjoy your dessert while hitting your goals. This Cosmic Brownie Protein Ice Cream Ninja Creami Fairlife recipe is perfect for post-workout or random cravings.
Biscoff Protein Ice Cream
Macros for the WHOLE Pint w/mix-ins:
400 Cals, 35g Carbs, 12g Fat, 38g Protein
Macros for the WHOLE Pint w/out mix-ins:
231 Cals, 15g Carbs, 3g Fat, 36g Protein
Satisfy your sweet tooth with this creamy Fairlife Ninja Creami recipe featuring rich Biscoff flavor and a protein boost. Made with Fairlife milk and vanilla whey/casein blend, this Ninja Creami Fairlife protein ice cream clocks in at just 231 calories and 36g of protein without mix-ins or 400 calories and 38g of protein with the Biscoff cookie butter and cookies. Fairlife milk in this Ninja Creami recipe creates a smooth creamy texture and better macros. This Biscoff Protein Ice Cream recipe is perfect for anyone craving a guilt-free indulgence or for fueling up post-workout.
Tips on Making Ninja Creami Fairlife Protein Ice Cream
Blend the Base Thoroughly Before Freezing
Add all ingredients to a pint and use a blender to mix. If you have a frother, you can use it too.
Add Sugar-Free Pudding Mix or Greek Yogurt for Density
These are very helpful ingredients because they do two things really well:
- Boosts flavor and also improves texture.
- They act as thickeners to improve texture, reduce iciness, and stabilize these low-fat/low-sugar protein ice creams.
If you don’t have either of these ingredients on hand, here is what I recommend to still get that great texture and flavor. Use either Xanthan Gum or Guar Gum. Start off with only 1-2g. Be precise and use a food scale because they are potent.
Freeze Flat for 18–24 Hours Minimum
For best results freeze ice cream base for up to 24hrs.
Pro tip: Ensure that you freeze your ice cream without the cover as you don’t get a hump, which can break your Ninja Creami machine.
What Can You Use Instead of Fairlife in Ninja Creami?
For Dairy-Free Alternatives
You can use all almond milk or any dairy-free milk. You can also use my normal recipe for the milk because Fairlife is already lactose-free.
If you use all almond milk, especially anything less than 50 calories per cup, it’ll be a tad bit less creamy because the water content is higher than dairy-free milk.
Other High-Protein Substitutes
Substituting with a vegan protein powder can suck but the ones I’ve created for recipes, won’t. You can substitute using a 1:1 ratio (e.g: If 30g protein is in the recipe, substitute with 30g of vegan protein powder).
Wrapping Up Our Ninja Creami Fairlife Recipe Guide
If you’re looking for ultra-creamy, high-protein ice cream, this Fairlife Ninja Creami recipe is where it’s at. Using Fairlife milk gives your base that smooth, rich texture while packing in the protein making it the perfect ninja creami fairlife protein ice cream. One of the most common questions people ask me is why use Fairlife milk in Ninja Creami recipes. The answer is simple: it’s ultra-filtered, higher in protein, and lower in sugar and carbs, which makes it ideal for macro-friendly desserts. Bookmark this recipe because it’ll become a go-to for flavor and function.
- Fruity Pebble Cereal Milk Protein Ice Cream
- Birthday Cake Batter Protein Ice Cream
- Butterfinger Protein Ice Cream
- Reese’s Protein Ice Cream
- Oreo Cereal Milk Protein Ice Cream
- Frosted Lemonade Protein Ice Cream
- Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Protein Ice Cream
- Cosmic Brownie Protein Ice Cream
- Biscoff Protein Ice Cream
For even more variety and macro friendly creations we invite you to checkout our website