Reese's Ninja Creami Ice Cream Recipe
Featured Recipes:
Why Make Your Own Reese’s Ninja Creami Ice Cream?
You Control the Ingredients and Nutrition
One of the best parts about making Reese’s ninja creami ice cream at home is that you know exactly what’s going into it. Instead of settling for sugar-loaded store-bought options, you get to control the sweetness, protein, and calorie count in each pint. Whether you’re crafting a higher-protein Reese’s protein ice cream or trying to dial back the fat, your mix-ins and base ingredients are entirely in your hands. It’s your Reese’s ice cream recipe, made your way.
Better Macros for Flexible Dieting
The classic Reese’s ice cream recipe tastes amazing, but it’s usually loaded with a heavy amount of fat and sugar. When you make this version, you can recreate all that chocolate-peanut butter flavor with way better macros. You can add protein powder, use low-fat milk, and scale your mix-ins to fit in your day. That’s what makes Reese’s protein ice cream the perfect treat for anyone tracking calories and macros while still enjoying dessert.
It’s a Whole Lot of Fun!
Let’s be honest, making a Reese’s ninja creami creation is just so fun. From building the perfect base, to watching your ice cream transform in seconds, the experience of making it is just as enjoyable as the final product tastes. Plus, experimenting with new spins on your go-to Reese’s ice cream recipe keeps things exciting and delicious. When a dessert hits your cravings and your macros, like Reese’s protein ice cream, you know you’re doing flexible dieting right.
Homemade Reese's Ice Cream Recipe and Step-by-Step Guide
Ingredients and Equipment You’ll Need
Base Ingredients
- 225g Fat Free Fairlife Milk
- 225g Unsweetened Vanilla Almond Milk
- 15g Flex Vanilla Whey/Casein Blend Protein Powder
- 15g Flex Peanut Butter Party Protein Cookie Butter Powder
- 15g Powdered Peanut Butter (PBfit or similar)
- 8g Sugar Free/Fat Free Butterscotch Pudding Mix
- 5g Zero-Calorie Sweetener of your choice
- Pinch of sea salt
Mix-ins:
- 1 Reese’s Snack Size Peanut Butter Cup (chopped)
- 10g Kashi Go Lean Peanut Butter Cereal
Step 1: Make the Ice Cream Base
Add all the base ingredients into your Ninja Creami pint. Use a small hand blender or frother to blend until it is completely smooth. This gives your ice cream that creamy, smooth texture after spinning.
Step 2: Freeze Properly
Place your pint in the freezer for at least 12–24 hours until it’s fully solid. Pro tip: Make multiple Reese’s ninja creami pints at once so you’re stocked for the week. Trust us, one pint is never enough!
Step 3: Spin to Creamy Perfection
Once it is fully frozen, load your pint into the Ninja Creami. Use the “Lite Ice Cream” function. After the first spin, you’ll have a soft, creamy Reese’s protein ice cream that’s packed with flavor and hits your daily macros.
Step 4: Add Mix-Ins
For a true Reese’s ice cream recipe experience, make a hole in the center of the pint and add your chopped Reese’s cup and peanut butter cereal. Run the “Mix-Ins” function to combine everything evenly.
Step 5: Serve and Store
Enjoy and serve immediately for peak texture, or re-spin after storing if you save it for later. Now you have just made an epic Reese’s ninja creami creation that is high-protein, macro-friendly, and way more satisfying than anything from a store.
Variations You Can Try With This Reese's Protein Ice Cream Base
Reese’s Protein Ice Cream
Macros for the WHOLE Pint w/out Mix-Ins:
404 Cals, 30g Carbs, 8g Fat, 53g Protein
Macros for the WHOLE Pint w/Mix-Ins:
526 Cals, 44g Carbs, 14g Fat, 56g Protein
This Reese’s Ninja Creami flavor blends childhood nostalgia with grown-up macros. Made with real Reese’s and a creamy protein base, this Reese’s ice cream recipe spins perfectly in your Ninja Creami and hits 53g of protein for the whole pint and is 404 calories with the mix-ins. It’s a must-try Reese’s Protein Ice Cream that feels indulgent but also fits your goals.
Other Reese’s Recipes and Dessert Delights We Have in Store For You
Reese’s Uncrustable Protein Pop-Tarts
Macros for each Reese’s Protein Pop Tart w/out Reese’s Pieces on top:
211 Cals, 23g Carbs, 3g Fat, 23g Protein
Macros with Reese’s Toppings:
270 Cals, 31g Carbs, 6g Fat, 23g Protein
These Reese’s protein pop tarts are unreal. Soft, chocolatey, and stuffed with peanut butter flavor, they’re everything you’d want from a Reese’s-inspired treat but in a macro friendly form. Try one of Reese’s Uncrustable Protein Pop-Tarts with your next batch of Reese’s Ninja Creami to double down on the flavor. It’s a solid addition to any Reese’s protein ice cream snack board.
Protein Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups
Macros per PB cup:
93 Cals, 7g Carbs, 5g Fat, 5g Protein
Skip the store-bought candy and make your own Reese’s Protein Peanut Butter Cups. At just 93 calories per cup with 5g protein each, they’re rich, salty, and perfect for pairing with a scoop of Reese’s Ninja Creami. They’re the kind of Reese’s ice cream recipe topper that takes your dessert game to the next level.
1/2lb Air Fryer Peanut Butter Protein Breakfast Brownie
Macros for the WHOLE Brownie:
415 Cals, 51g Carbs, 7g Fat, 37g Protein, 10g Fiber
This 1/2lb breakfast brownie is everything. It’s rich in peanut butter flavor with 37g of protein, and it’s the ideal warm base for scooping Reese’s Ninja Creami right on top. If you’re into hot and cold combos, this Reese’s protein ice cream pairing with a 1/2lb Air Fryer Peanut Butter Breakfast Brownie is unbeatable. It’s definitely one of the more creative Reese’s ice cream recipes you’ll crave again and again.
Wrapping Up Our Reece's Ninja Creami Recipe
If you’ve been craving something indulgent without throwing off your goals, this Reese’s Ninja Creami creation is your answer. It’s everything you love about peanut butter and chocolate only lighter, higher in protein, and built to fit your macros. From the rich, creamy base to the crunchy mix-ins, this Reese’s protein ice cream delivers flavor and flexibility in every spoonful.
Unlike a store-bought Reese’s ice cream recipe, you control the calories, sweetness, and mix-ins, so you get all the satisfaction with none of the guesswork. Whether you’re satisfying a late-night craving or prepping your weekly freezer stash, this recipe proves that macro friendly can still be fun, indulgent, and ridiculously good.
Try it once, and you’ll want to keep it on repeat!
- Reese’s Protein Ice Cream
- Reese’s Uncrustable Protein Pop-Tarts
- Protein Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups
- 1/2lb Air Fryer Peanut Butter Breakfast Brownie
For even more variety and macro friendly creations we invite you to checkout our website and in case you missed our favorite sweets list we have them here: