Ninja Creami Peanut Butter Ice Cream
Featured Recipes:
Why You’ll Love Ninja Creami Peanut Butter Protein Ice Cream
All the Peanut Butter Flavor Without the Sugar Overload
If you’re all about enjoying that rich peanut butter flavor but you’re not into the sugar crash that comes afterwards, this ninja creami peanut butter ice cream is about to be your go-to recipe. It’s creamy, high in protein, and totally customizable. Whether you want to eat just one scoop or you’re dreaming of eating an entire pint of ninja creami chocolate peanut butter ice cream, you’ll love how easy this is to make. And you’ll also learn exactly how to make peanut butter ice cream in Ninja Creami without ruining your macros for the day. Keep reading to learn how to make it.
How to Make Ninja Creami Peanut Butter Ice Cream
Essential Ingredients for a Creamy Peanut Butter Base
- 225g Fat Free Fairlife Milk
- 225g Unsweetened Vanilla Almond Milk
- 15g Flex Vanilla Whey/Casein Blend Protein Powder
- 15g Flex Peanut Butter Party Protein Cookie Butter Powder
- 15g Powdered Peanut Butter
- 8g Sugar Free/Fat Free Butterscotch Pudding Mix
- 5g Zero Calorie Sweetener of your choice
- Pinch of Sea Salt
Step-by-Step Instructions to Nail the Texture
- Place all of your ingredients into your Ninja Creami pint. Use a small hand blender and mix until smooth.
- Place the pint in the freezer until it is frozen. I freeze mine the day before so it can freeze overnight. Pro tip: Grab six extra pints and then make them at one time so you have ice cream for the whole week.
- Once it’s frozen, add it to your creami holster and press the “Lite Ice Cream” function. After this first spin, you’ll have an incredible protein peanut butter ice cream!
- If you want a Reese’s flavor, make a hole in the middle of the ice cream and add your mix-ins in the hole. Press the mix-ins function and enjoy!
What to Do If It’s Too Powdery or Too Icy
This may depend on the timing and the speed of the blade. I normally use the “Ice Cream”, “Lite Ice Cream” and “Sorbet” functions. Run the “Ice Cream” function if you want a dense ice cream rather than a lighter soft serve style consistency.
The ice cream setting runs for only 60 seconds and has a lower blade speed thus allowing for a denser end product because less air has been whipped into it. Once it’s finished running, you can assess and see if it’s the consistency you desire. I recommend only running it once especially if you are adding mix-ins. You’ll want to be careful how many times you run it through because it’ll start to melt.
More Delicious and Nutritious Ninja Creami Protein Recipes Worth Trying
Reese’s Cereal Milk Protein Ice Cream
Macros for the WHOLE Pint w/out Mix-Ins:
351 Cals, 31g Carbs, 7g Fat, 41g Protein
Macros for the WHOLE Pint w/Reese’s Puff Mix-Ins:
413 Cals, 41g Carbs, 9g Fat, 42g Protein
This one brings back pure childhood nostalgia with a macro friendly twist. It’s loaded with a peanut buttery flavor, cereal milk creaminess, and a ridiculous 42g of protein and 413 calories with mix-ins. If you’re craving a chocolate peanut butter combo, this Reese’s Cereal Milk Protein Ice Cream ninja creami chocolate peanut butter ice cream inspired treat is a must try. It blends Reese’s Puffs, powdered peanut butter, and a butterscotch pudding mix for a sweet-savory hit that somehow tastes like both breakfast and dessert.
Cinnamon Toast Crunch Waffle Cereal Milk Protein Ice Cream
Macros for the WHOLE Pint w/out Mix-Ins:
284 Cals, 26g Carbs, 4g Fat, 36g Protein
Macros for the WHOLE Pint w/Cinnamon Toast Crunch Mix-Ins:
374 Cals, 42g Carbs, 6g Fat, 38g Protein
If you’ve ever wanted cereal milk ice cream with a protein punch, then this is it. This Cinnamon Toast Crunch Waffle Cereal Milk Protein ninja creami peanut butter ice cream inspired combination has 38g of protein, 374 calories with mix-ins, cinnamon waffle cereal vibes, and a drizzle of sugar-free breakfast pancake syrup. It’s creamy, crunchy, and macro friendly. Are you curious about how to make peanut butter ice cream in Ninja Creami? This recipe puts a cereal spin on it that totally works.
Fruity Pebble Cereal Milk Protein Ice Cream
Macros for the WHOLE Pint w/out Mix-Ins:
284 Cals, 26g Carbs, 4g Fat, 36g Protein
Macros for the WHOLE Pint w/Fruity Pebble Mix-Ins:
365 Cals, 43g Carbs, 5g Fat, 37g Protein
This one’s straight up cereal milk magic. The fruity Pebbles bring a bright, nostalgic flavor while still keeping things macro friendly at 37g of protein and 365 calories with mix-ins. It’s creamy, sweet, and has just the right amount of crunch. Fruity Pebble Cereal Milk Protein proves even fun flavors can fuel you right. And if you’re wondering how to make peanut butter ice cream in Ninja Creami, this base is the perfect starting point – just swap the cereal for peanut butter and that’s it.
Cinnamon Toast Crunch Cheesecake Protein Ice Cream
Macros for WHOLE Pint w/out Mix-Ins:
301 Cals, 20g Carbs, 5g Fat, 44g Protein
Macros for Whole Pint with Mix-Ins:
399 Cals, 29g Carbs, 11g Fat, 46g Protein
This one tastes like a peanut butter cheesecake swirl and it’s loaded with 46g of protein and 399 calories with mix-ins. You get a creamy peanut butter base, cinnamon warmth, and a little crunch from Cinnamon Toast Crunch. It’s the kind of ninja creami peanut butter ice cream that satisfies dessert cravings and matches your macro goals. If you’re curious about how to make peanut butter ice cream in Ninja Creami, Cinnamin Toast Crunch Cheesecake Protein Ice Cream is your go-to flavor combo – bonus points for that frozen cream cheese swirl.
Coffee Oreo Chip Protein Ice Cream
Macros for WHOLE Pint Coffee Base:
226 Cals, 16g Carbs, 2g Fat, 36g Protein
Macros for WHOLE Pint w/Mix-Ins:
339 Cals, 33g Carbs, 7g Fat, 36g Protein
Coffee lovers, this one’s for you. This Coffee OREO Chip Protein Ice Cream blends rich cold brew coffee with creamy vanilla protein for a refreshing high protein treat at only 226 calories and 36g protein without mix-ins. Add Oreo Thins and mini chips for the full effect which brings the calories to 399 kcals.. While it’s not your classic ninja creami peanut butter protein ice cream, this flavor hits just as hard, smooth, indulgent, and macro friendly. Want to learn how to make peanut butter ice cream in Ninja Creami? Stay tuned for the next drop.
Parting Thoughts on How to Make Peanut Butter Ice Cream in Ninja Creami
Once you figure out how to make peanut butter ice cream in the Ninja Creami, you’ll realize how easy it is to turn your favorite dessert into a protein packed treat. You can go full on with ninja creami peanut butter ice cream, try a swirl of chocolate for ninja creami chocolate peanut butter ice cream, or level it up with protein powder for a ninja creami peanut butter protein ice cream version. This machine gives you endless flavor flexibility. Swap out different mix-ins, experiment with powders, and have fun making your own macro friendly masterpiece.
- Reese’s Cereal Milk Protein Ice Cream
- Cinnamon Toast Crunch Waffle Cereal Milk Protein Ice Cream
- Fruity Pebble Cereal Milk Protein Ice Cream
- Cinnamon Toast Crunch Cheesecake Protein Ice Cream
- Coffee Oreo Chip Protein Ice Cream
For even more variety and macro friendly creations we invite you to checkout our website