Homemade Cherry Garcia Ice Cream
Featured Recipes:
Why You’ll Love Our DIY Cherry Garcia Ice Cream
A Healthier Take on a Classic Favorite
Cherry garcia ice cream is a cult classic ice cream flavor that combines the sweet and tart flavors of chocolate fudge and fresh cherries that make an irresistible treat. Though this flavor combination seems to be a match made in heaven, it’s traditional ingredients beyond the cherries and fudge can really mess up your macros. Our homemade cherry garcia ice cream takes care of that problem.
Perfect for Flexible Dieting Goals
This homemade cherry garcia ice cream recipe that we created is perfect for fitting into your daily macros, which is something we love here at Flexible Dieting Lifestyle. It doesn’t contain a crazy amount of sugar, carbs or fat. It contains just the right amount of everything to make it healthy and delicious.
Fresh, Customizable, and Fun to Make
This is hands down the best cherry garcia ice cream recipe that you’ll want to make on a weekly basis. Once you get the hang of the original recipe, you may want to make a few tweeks to make it perfect for you, And you know what? You absolutely can! That’s the beauty behind this homemade cherry garcia ice cream. You can customize it and make it your own. This also makes it fun to make. That way, you’ll never get bored with it.
What You’ll Need for Our Homemade Cherry Garcia Ice Cream Recipe
Base Ingredients
- 240g Fairlife Fat Free Milk
- 30g Vanilla Whey/Casein Blend Protein Powder
- 8g Sugar Free/Fat Free White Chocolate Pudding Mix
- 5g Zero Cal Sweetener of your choice
- Pinch of Sea Salt
- 200g No Sugar Added Cherry
- Pie Filling
Mix-Ins:
- 4 Pitted Cherries
- 15g Dark Chocolate
Flavor Additions
One of the best parts about making homemade cherry garcia ice cream is how easy it is to switch things up. Love extra chocolate? Add more fudge swirls or mini chocolate chips. Want a fruitier twist? Toss in more fresh cherries or even a handful of raspberries. Since this is a DIY cherry garcia ice cream, you’re free to experiment with flavors until you find your personal favorite. That’s why we call it the best cherry garcia ice cream recipe, it’s endlessly customizable and fun to create.
How to Make Homemade Cherry Garcia Ice Cream
Step 1: Prepare Your Ice Cream Base
Add all your ingredients into your pint (except pie filling). Use small hand blender and mix till smooth.
Step 2: Incorporate Cherries and Chocolate
Add your no sugar added pie filling.
Step 3: Chill or Freeze the Mixture
Add pint to the freezer till frozen. I just do mine the day before so they can freeze overnight. And also pro tip, get extra pints and then make 6 of these at one time so you have them for the whole week.
Step 4: Spin, Scoop, and Serve
Then once frozen, add to your creami holster and do the “Ice Cream” function. I use this function instead of lite ice cream when I want to add mix-ins.
Enhance With Toppings
Now if you want mix-ins, make a hole in the middle of the ice cream to make sure the mix-ins get evenly dispersed throughout the pint. Add your cherries and chocolate chips. Add back to the creami and do the mix-ins function. Then enjoy!
Storage Guidelines
Once you’ve made your homemade cherry garcia ice cream, you’ll definitely want to keep it fresh for as long as possible. Store your batch in an airtight container in the freezer to maintain that creamy texture and bold flavor. If using a Ninja Creami or similar device, simply re-spin before serving to bring it back to life. Since this is a lighter, DIY cherry garcia ice cream, it may harden a bit more than store-bought options, but that’s easily fixed.
Other Fan Favorite Homemade Ice Cream Recipes You Should Try
Blueberry Cheesecake Protein Ice Cream
Macros for WHOLE Pint Blueberry Base (no mix-ins):
342 Cals, 43g Carbs, 2g Fat, 38g Protein
Macros for WHOLE Pint with mix-ins:
428 Cals, 49g Carbs, 8g Fat, 40g Protein
Making homemade cherry garcia ice cream proves you can enjoy classic desserts without sacrificing nutrition, and this Blueberry Cheesecake Protein Ice Cream version follows the same blueprint. Fresh blueberries, protein powder, and sugar-free cheesecake pudding mix make it creamy, fruity, and macro friendly. Similar to our homemade cherry garcia ice cream recipe, this one is customizable and packed with flavor. It’s light enough for daily enjoyment but indulgent enough to crush cravings. If you’ve ever wondered what the best cherry garcia ice cream recipe could inspire, this recipe shows you how flexible dessert can be. That’s the beauty of experimenting with DIY cherry garcia ice cream style creations.
Red Velvet Oreo Cheesecake Protein Ice Cream
Macros for the WHOLE Pint w/all mix ins:
428 Cals, 33g Carbs, 12g Fat, 47g Protein
Just like crafting homemade cherry garcia ice cream, this Red Velvet Oreo Cheesecake Protein Ice Cream delivers that wow factor while staying macro-friendly. It combines Fairlife milk, protein powder, sugar-free cheesecake pudding mix, and red velvet extract for bold flavor and a velvety texture. Think of it as a cousin to the homemade cherry garcia ice cream recipe, indulgent yet balanced. With its rich taste and creamy base, it feels like a bakery-style dessert without the guilt. If you’ve been hunting for the best cherry garcia ice cream recipe inspiration but want to try something different, this DIY cherry garcia ice cream method proves you can reinvent any flavor.
Biscoff Protein Ice Cream
Macros for the WHOLE Pint w/mix-ins:
400 Cals, 35g Carbs, 12g Fat, 38g Protein
Macros for the WHOLE Pint w/out mix-ins:
231 Cals, 15g Carbs, 3g Fat, 36g Protein
If you’ve ever made homemade cherry garcia ice cream, you know how fun it is to create indulgent flavors that still fit your macros. This Biscoff Protein Ice Cream version takes the same approach, creamy, sweet, and satisfying without the overload of sugar and fat. Just like our homemade cherry garcia ice cream recipe, this one uses Fairlife milk, whey/casein protein, and sugar-free cheesecake pudding mix for the perfect texture. It’s a treat that feels decadent but works with your goals. If you’re searching for the best cherry garcia ice cream recipe style of dessert inspiration, this spin proves that DIY cherry garcia ice cream concepts work for any flavor.
Final Thoughts on the Best Cherry Garcia Ice Cream Recipe
If you’ve ever wondered how to enjoy Cherry Garcia without crushing your macros, our homemade cherry garcia ice cream is the answer. This treat gives you all the classic flavors, rich chocolate fudge and tart cherries in a lighter, more balanced way. Instead of heavy, sugar-packed ingredients, our homemade cherry garcia ice cream recipe is crafted to fit flexible dieting goals without sacrificing taste.
- Cherry Garcia Ice Cream
- Blueberry Cheesecake Protein Ice Cream
- Red Velvet Oreo Protein Ice Cream
- Biscoff Protein Ice Cream
For even more variety and macro friendly creations we invite you to checkout our website and in case you missed our favorite sweets list we have them here: