Ninja Creami Cookies and Cream Recipe
Featured Recipes:
Why You’ll Love This Cookies and Cream Ninja Creami Recipe
Easy to Modify Based on Dietary Needs
Cookies and cream ice cream in Ninja Creami machines are easy to make with any dietary preference. Here;s how:
Milks: You can use almond milk or any dairy-free milk alternative. This recipe uses Fairlife milk which is lactose-free.
If you decide to use almond milk, specifically a brand that contains 50 calories or less per cup, the final ice cream will be less creamy, because of the high water content.
Protein Powder: Substituting with a vegan protein can suck, but not if you use the ones we’ve created.
You can substitute using a 1:1 ratio (e.g. If 30g protein powder is in the recipe, substitute with 30g vegan protein powder).
Cookie Butter: Just like you can substitute regular protein powder with vegan protein powder, you can do the same with cookie butter! If you want the best vegan products in the game, my vegan cookie butters are insane. It’s literally a diet saver if you are lactose intolerant. I highly recommend starting with Brownie Batter and Blueberry Pastry cookie butters for this cookies and cream ice cream in Ninja Creami recipe.
And if you do not have cookie butter, I’d recommend just substituting with powdered peanut butter. It won’t be the same but it’ll be close enough.
Ninja Creami Cookies and Cream Recipe: Ingredients, Instructions, and Tips for Making it Your Own
Core Ingredients for a Perfect Creami Base
- 240g Fairlife Fat Free Milk
- 240g Unsweetened Vanilla Almond Milk
- 30g Flex Vanilla Whey/Casein Blend Protein Powder
- 8g Sugar Free/Fat Free White Chocolate Pudding Mix
- 5g Zero Cal Sweetener of your choice
- Pinch of Sea Salt
Mix-Ins:
- 4 OREO Thins
Step-by-Step Instructions for a Creamy, Scoopable Result
- Add all the ingredients (except the Oreos) into a pint. Use a small hand blender and mix until smooth.
- Place the pint in the freezer until it is frozen. I freeze mine the day before so it can freeze overnight.
- Once it is frozen, add it to your creami holster and press the “Lite Ice Cream” function. One time should be enough.
- If you want to add mix-ins, make a hole in the middle of the ice cream and add in the OREO thins.
- Place the holster back on the creami and press the mix-ins function. Enjoy!
Pro Tip:
- Grab 6 extra pints to prep a whole week’s worth of ice cream all at once!
- Make sure to thaw out the edges of the pint before spinning it by running it under warm water for 60 seconds.
- If there is a dry crumbly consistency after running it through the first time, add a splash of milk before doing a re-spin. This usually doesn’t happen to me, but it does happen to a lot of you.
- Your protein powder matters a TON because it’s a huge part of the recipe. The taste and the consistency will largely depend on this. It’s why I created flex_brands, aka the best protein for recipes.
Tips to Personalize and Perfect the Texture
The difference for each one is based on the time and speed of the blade. I normally use the “Ice Cream”, “Lite Ice Cream”, and “Sorbet” functions.
Perform the “Ice Cream” function if you want a dense ice cream rather than a lighter soft serve style consistency.
This setting is only 60 seconds in duration because the blade speed is lower. This allows for a denser end product due to less air being whipped into it. Once the function is done, you can assess and see if it’s the consistency you want.
I recommend running it only once, especially if you are doing mix-ins. This is because it will start to melt.
Why is My Ninja Cream Cookies and Cream Ice Cream Still so Crumbly?
Perform the “Lite Ice Cream” function one time. It’ll be dry and a little crumbly-looking. Do a re-spin and it’ll be perfect after that.
Add Some of Our Other Ninja Creami Recipes to Your Rotation!
Apple Pie Protein Ice Cream
Macros for the Whole Pint:
285 Cals, 33g Carbs, 1g Fat, 36g Protein
If you’re obsessed with the Ninja Creami cookies and cream recipe trend but want a fall-inspired twist, this Apple Pie Protein Ice Cream is it. Warm spices, sweet apple pie filling, and a creamy protein-packed base at 285 calories and 36g protein, make this a cozy game-changer. It’s macro-friendly, easy to prep, and loaded with nostalgic flavor. Your Ninja Creami needs this one in rotation.
Pumpkin Pie Protein Ice Cream
Macros for the WHOLE Pint:
290 Calories, 30g Protein, 2g Fat, 38g Protein
This Pumpkin Pie Protein Ice Cream is creamy, spiced, and perfect for fall cravings year-round. With real pumpkin, warm spices, and a dreamy texture, this 290 calories and 38g of protein treat is a hard to believe macro-friendly ice cream. If you’re into cookies and cream ninja creami creations but want something seasonal and cozy, this one’s a must-try. Easy to prep, crazy delicious, and made for your Ninja Creami.
Crunch Bar Protein Ice Cream
Macros for the WHOLE Pint with Crunch Layer:
393 Cals, 40g Carbs, 9g Fat, 38g Protein
This isn’t your average protein ice cream. It’s a creamy, crunchy, Ninja Creami masterpiece. Packed with a nostalgic chocolate shell and crispy bites at only 393 calories and 38g of protein, this Crunch Bar Protein Ice Cream delivers serious flavor. If you love ninja creami cookies and cream recipe, but want something with a candy bar twist, this one’s for you. That crunch layer is a game changer. Grab your Ninja Creami and let’s level up your post-workout treat.
Red Velvet Oreo Cheesecake Protein Ice Cream
Macros for the WHOLE Pint w/all mix ins:
428 Cals, 33g Carbs, 12g Fat, 47g Protein
This Red Velvet Oreo Cheesecake combo is wild in the best way. It’s creamy, tangy, chocolatey, and packed with 47g of protein and 428 calories. If you’re hunting for a ninja creami cookies and cream recipe with a unique twist, this one hits the mark. The red velvet extract gives it a bold flavor, and the pudding mix makes it extra smooth. This isn’t your average cookies and cream ninja creami creation, it’s dessert designed with serious macro goals in mind.
Wrapping Up Our Guide to Making Your Cookies and Cream Ninja Creami Ice Cream
Now you’ve got the full breakdown to make the ultimate ninja creami cookies and cream recipe right at home. Whether you’re keeping it classic or adding your favorite mix-ins, this protein-packed treat delivers on flavor and macros. Cookies and cream ice cream in Ninja Creami machines that’s actually macro-friendly is 100% doable and ridiculously satisfying. Bookmark this go-to cookies and cream Ninja Creami recipe so you’re always ready for dessert that hits your goals and your sweet tooth.
- Apple Pie Protein Ice Cream
- Pumpkin Pie Protein Ice Cream
- Crunch Bar Protein Ice Cream
- Red Velvet Oreo Cheesecake Protein Ice Cream
For even more variety and macro friendly creations we invite you to checkout our website.